• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Butter Nutrition
  • About
    • Contact
  • Praise
  • Services
    • Free Consult
  • Blog
  • Quiz
  • Contact
menu icon
go to homepage
  • About
    • Contact
  • Praise
  • Services
    • Free Consult
  • Blog
  • Quiz
  • Contact
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • About
    • Contact
  • Praise
  • Services
    • Free Consult
  • Blog
  • Quiz
  • Contact
×
Home » Uncategorized

Protein Powder Rankings: Which is Best?

Modified: Aug 13, 2025 · Published: Oct 11, 2018 by Catherine Crow, NTP · Medical Disclaimer · This Post Contains Affiliate Links 2 Comments

Protein Powder Ranking: What is Best? | Butter NutritionLet's talk protein powder rankings, because sometimes you just don't want or feel like cooking so you can eat real food. Like at all. But you know you need to eat something or things won't be pretty.

This post is for those moments. When finding something to eat is a feels like a chore that makes your head hurt a little.

Protein Powder Rankings

Most protein powder tastes like chalk, quite literally. It's gross, and most I've tried go immediately down the drain after a single sip. But I wanted to give this protein powder thing one more go. Historically, collagen protein has been my go-to protein mix-in for the last 5+ years, but it's not something that you want to use too much of (more on why coming here soon).

I was pretty selective when picking out protein powders to try and rank. Ideally you want something with only a few ingredients, minimal gut irritating additives, and something free of all the common food sensitivities like: soy, whey, casein, and gluten. My reviews are pretty brief because let's face it, something is either edible or inedible, right?!

Sun Warrior Blend- Vanilla Review

Ingredients: Proprietary blend (organic pea protein‚ organic hemp protein‚ organic goji berry)‚ organic vanilla flavor‚ organic guar gum‚sea salt‚ organic stevia extract‚ organic whole ground coconut.
Pros: plant-based for those of you who like eating more plants 🙂
Cons: tastes like chalk, contains guar gum
Verdict: inedible
Shop: Find this one here.

Paleo Protein Powder - Vanilla Review

Ingredients: grass-fed lean beef protein, egg protein, natural flavors, monk fruit extract, sunflower lecithin
Pros: doesn't taste like chalk, solid ingredient list
Cons: on the spendy side
Verdict: edible
Shop: Find this one here.

Paleo Protein Powder - Chocolate Review

Ingredients: grass-fed lean beef protein, egg protein, natural flavors, monk fruit extract, sunflower lecithin
Pros: doesn't taste like chalk, solid ingredient list
Cons: expensive
Verdict: edible
Shop: Find this one here.

Manitoba Harvest Hemp Pro 70 - Original Review

Ingredients: hemp protein concentrate, natural plan extracts
Pros: clean, only two ingredients
Cons: tastes like dirt
Verdict: inedible
Shop: Find this one here.

Amazing Grass Protein Superfood Review

Ingredients: Green Food Blend (Organic Wheat Grass, Organic Alfalfa, Organic Barley Grass, Organic Spinach, Organic Spirulina, Organic Chlorella (cracked cell-wall), Organic Broccoli); Protein Blend (Organic Pea Protein, Organic Hemp Protein, Organic Chia, Organic Quinoa); Fruit & Vegetable Blend (Organic Açai, Organic Banana, Organic Beet, Organic Carrot, Organic Goji, Organic Pineapple, Organic Sweet Potato, Organic Raspberry, Organic Rose Hips). Other Ingredients: Organic Peanut Flour, Natural Flavors, Organic Cocoa, Salt, Xanthan Gum, Organic Stevia. Contains Peanuts.
Pros: #healthy, contains a variety of fruits and veggies
Cons: contains natural flavors and xanthan gum
Verdict: inedible - absolutely awful. This one fell at the end of the protein powder rankings list for taste.
Shop: Find this one here.

How I use this Protein Powder

As you can see PaleoPro was the clear winner. I don't know about you, but I'm willing to spend more on something that's edible and has well-sourced ingredients.

Here's how I'm using this protein powder as of lately. As you can see I still think it's important to add more than just protein powder to your shake.

Protein Shake:

  • 1 cup milk of choice (I typically use homemade coconut milk)
  • 1 frozen ripe banana
  • 3 frozen drip coffee ice cubes (optional)
  • Tablespoon-ish nut butter of choice (I use peanut butter or cashew butter)
  • Tablespoon-ish Cacao powder (like this)
  • ½ scoop PaleoPro Vanilla (like this)
  • 1 tablespoon collagen powder (like this)
  • 1 tablespoon maple syrup (optional)
  • ¼ teaspoon vanilla extract (optional)
  • Pinch of salt

Just mix up all of this in the blender and enjoy! I do not ever recommend mixing protein powders in with a spoon, it just never works out too well.

What's your winner in the protein powder rankings? Please share in the comments!

PIN IT:
Protein Powder Rankings: What is Best? | Butter Nutrition

Protein Powder Rankings: What is Best? | Butter Nutrition

 

More Articles You May Enjoy

  • How To Fix Your Gut | Butter Nutrition
    How To Fix Your Gut
  • Organ Rotation Diet | Butter Nutrition
    An Alternative to Multivitamins
  • 5 Must-Have Cold Remedies
  • 6 Signs You Should Consider Food Sensitivity Testing | Butter Nutrition
    7 Signs You Should Try Food Sensitivity Testing (+ what I learned from it) *UPDATED*

About Catherine Crow, NTP

Hi there! I’m Catherine Crow. Seattle-based Functional Nutritional Therapy Practitioner (FNTP), Educator, Diet Investigator, and Coconut Milk Ice Cream Enthusiast. My goal is to help guide you to improve your nutrition through strategic eating (not dieting) and without expensive supplements. Because when you know better, you can feel better! Read more...

Want the FREE Recipe eBook?

The Nutritionally Wealthy Recipes eBook is finally yours for FREE! It includes over 40 nutrient-dense and gluten-free recipes, as well as a few recipes for your skin. As a gift to my wonderful readers, you can download it for FREE today and tomorrow only! So grab it now below :)
Free Download: The Nutritionally Wealthy eBook | Butter Nutrition

Affiliate Link Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Please note: using an affiliate link does not change the price of the product, instead the seller pays Butter Nutrition a small commission. My thoughts on these products are my own.

Paid Endorsement Disclosure: In order for me to support my blogging activities, I may receive monetary compensation or other types of remuneration for my endorsement, recommendation, testimonial and/or link to any products or services from this blog.

Reader Interactions

Comments

    Join the Conversation Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Becky

    October 11, 2018 at 10:17 am

    I LOVE making a shake just with water or almond milk, Ancient Nutrition Bone Broth Protein and a scoop of Fruits & Greens from NutriDyn. It's the perfect mid-afternoon energy boost that I need!

    Reply
  2. Chantal Guilbault

    October 12, 2018 at 7:12 am

    I use Nutiva hemp protein almost every day. I wanted a neutral protein powder, not chocolate or vanilla. I use a cup of greens, usually spinach, 1/2 a frozen banana and one other fruit, my favorites are pineapple or mango. It’s filling and I like the taste, the key I think is the banana, makes it creamier. It tastes healthy for sure but it makes me feel good 🙂

    Reply

Primary Sidebar

Hi, I'm Catherine! As a nutritional therapist, my passion is education. My goal is to help guide you to improve your nutrition through strategic eating (not dieting) and without expensive supplements! Because when you know better, you can feel better! More about me →

Follow on

Take the Quiz!

Quiz: Is nutrient excess ruining your health?

Get your free customized results!

Take the Quiz

Popular Posts

  • VItamin D Lab Testing
    Are You Really Vitamin D Deficient? 4 Things to Consider
  • human body image highlighting the liver
    Is Your Chronic Gut Issue Really a Liver/Gallbladder Issue?
  • Cartoon liver health concept
    What To Do Instead of a Liver Detox
  • 6 scenarios that prove western medicine is cray-cray | Butter Nutrition
    8 Scenarios That Prove Western Medicine Is A Little CRAZY

 

Footer

↑ back to top

About

  • About Catherine
  • Client Praise
  • Media/Interviews/Guest Posts
  • Newsletter Sign Up

Fine Print

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Accessibility
  • Terms of Use

Contact

  • Contact
  • Services
  • Media Kit
  • FAQ

Copyright © 2025 Butter Nutrition LLC